In this episode, I sit down with Erin Ingold, co-founder of Metanoia Catholic, to begin a four-part conversation on the four temperaments: cholaric, melancholic, sanguine, and phlegmatic. Erin explains where the temperaments come from, how the Catholic tradition understands them, and how they can point us towards our individual strengths, weaknesses, and areas for growth in virtue. Temperaments aren’t meant to put us into a box. Rather they can give us a starting point for recognizing how God may be inviting us to grow and become more fully ourselves in Christ.
Reflection and Discussion Questions:
Understanding the foundational, biological part of our personality called our temperament can help us grow in self-knowledge and therefore, hopefully, make better decisions. Not just, as Claire pointed out, “vocational decisions or big life decisions, but even smaller decisions about how to grow in virtue.” What are some examples of decisions we make everyday: what time to get up; how much to eat; how long to pray; whether to stop and talk to our neighbor, for example, that shape the people that we are and that we are becoming? Give personal examples if you can.
Having heard an overview of the four temperaments, can you guess which one best describes you? Or perhaps you’ve taken an assessment and already know. It is possible that the Lord is inviting you to a deeper level of self-understanding? Not necessary that you are different than you originally thought (as Claire shared) but could there be aspects of your personality that you need to explore or develop?
Resources Mentioned:
A Spacious Place: A Spiritual Journey with Saint Edith Stein by Claire Dwyer
Use the code Partner2026 for 20% off!
We’d love to hear from you!
If this podcast has encouraged you, consider supporting Your Best Yes on Substack to help us continue creating conversations and resources to help others seek God’s will with greater clarity, confidence, and trust.











